About Us

How We Got Started

The story behind Clay Paul.

Meet Our Team

As brokers, we will shop dozens of insurance carriers on your behalf.

Matthew Arnold

Owner & Managing Partner

Justin Arnold

Owner & Managing Partner

Kelli Sherman

Service Director

Randy Mapston

Commercial Insurance Broker

Elyce Umana

Senior Account Executive

Rebeca Alvizo

Director Sales and Service, William Palmer Insurance Agency

Join Our Team

At the Clay Paul Insurance Agency, our primary focus is to be of service to our clients. We are currently experiencing rapid growth, due to positive word-of-mouth referrals, which means we are in need of dedicated and service-oriented insurance agents to join our team.

If you think your values align with ours, email your resume to [email protected] If you are an appropriate fit for our current needs, we’ll be in touch.